Why is he hiding me from his family? (Relationship and Dating Advice)

Other questions about dating across cultures: 

Why is he hiding our relationship from his family? 

Cultural Differences Part 1: Am I booty call? 

Cultural differences Part 2: Am I getting played? 

Different cultures; more than friends, less than lovers

Cross-cultural relationship; east meets west

________________________

Dear Guys,

My boyfriend is Asian. Let me just get that out of the way. We’ve dated for five months. His mother was Hispanic (I’m half white, half Hispanic) and his father is Asian. His mother died when he was still young, but his father remarried to an Asian. He hides me from everyone on the Asian side of the family, but lets the other half know about me all the time. He pretends we’re not together. I’ve tried talking but he just feels like it’s completely normal and okay to hide me. I’ve been distressed about this, but I’m trying to put it behind me. I need a little closure.

I love him so much and I know five months is still very young, but I just am the happiest person when we’re together.
I just am desperately looking for some sort of lifeline. Advice?

Amanda

Dear Amanda,

Thanks for your question. Why are you trying to put this issue behind you? This is not something you brush under the carpet. It’s a serious issue.

So does he know that this bothers you? (We can’t imagine he doesn’t.) But if not, you need to have a conversation with him immediately. If he’s embarrassed of you, or afraid that his father’s family will not approve of you, then how is the relationship really going to move forward? If he was truly serious about you he’d be telling everyone he knows about you. That’s what guys do. They are eager to show off their new girl to their friends and family. (Although, admittedly, sometimes the family introduction is a bit trickier.) But being nervous about introducing your new partner to your family, is different than intentionally hiding her. That’s what’s going on here.

We’ll be honest with you here. When a guy acts like this from the onset, it doesn’t usually end up well. Meaning, if he truly is hiding you, and really thinks that’s okay, we don’t see this relationship lasting for the long-term. Yes, you might force him to introduce you, but if he’s this uncomfortable now, and bowing to the pressure he feels from his father, do you really think he’ll go against his wishes when push comes to shove? (Like something more serious like marriage.) Not likely. (Please read some of the other posts on this topic above, and the comments beneath each of those posts. You’re not alone in this situation.)

We’re sorry. We wish we could be more uplifting and throw you that lifeline you were speaking of. But frankly, we think you need to hear what your gut is already telling you. And please understand this is coming from a supportive place, even though it may be hard to hear.

What do you think? What’s your plan? Feel free to ask as many follow-up questions as you’d like.

Take care,

THE GUYS

ps. We hope you’ll share our site with all of your friends. Follow us on Twitter: @TGPBuzz. And take a moment to VOTE on our Ask our Audience page. Thanks. We appreciate it.

If you’d like to donate to THE GUYS—use PayPal, on the right side of any page on our site—no donation is too small or too large.

 

8 Comments on Why is he hiding me from his family? (Relationship and Dating Advice)

  1. Hi im a muslim girl and im going through a lot of trouble right now with this guy. Basically we met in my first year of uni and we became really good friends and I fell for him. I kinda knew he liked me back and he did weird things like ignore me around his friends but be into me when we’re alone.i gathered this was because he is a very shy and reserved guy and has never had a gf before too. In second year we randomly just stopped talking and then he got in touch via facebook saying how he feels bad that we haven’t spoken. And I said yh I know I don’t get why youre ignoring me all the time. Anyway we made up and became close again. he admitted he had feelings for me and I said I did too. He’s muslim too btw. So obviously we knew we cant actually date etc as it would lead us to do wrong thing. We agreed to get to know each other more in this light then make a decision on whether to tell our parents. I was in such a happy place and we went out for a ‘date’.
    However he leaned in and kissed me and I realised that I don’t want to do this unless I know he’s actually committing. I told him how I felt that same evening and he started being vague saying ‘les just see what happens and don’t over think things’. I felt really crap inside and I was so heartbroken because I pinned my hopes on this guy to give me a future. Anyway we agreed to stay away from each other and to stop all contact. I deleted him off facebook and his number. the rest of uni was probably the hardest few months of my life, I still saw him around and id just die inside.
    Its third year now and I was in a good place knowing that he’d never talk to me again I didn’t have any expectations. However in October he got intouch with me via facebook apologising saying he’s sorry for everything and he never meant any of it to happen. I was so confused and told myself I wouldn’t reply to it as it was just too late for an apology now. But I really did want to just make up with him cos I still think about him all the time and miss him so much it kills me.
    I replied a week later saying I was confused about this and he told me he knows its late but hes made a mistake and hes sorry. I felt even more crap like he just came to tell me he made a mistake with me. I asked him if he wanted to talk cos I hate doing things online as its better to speak face-to-face. He didn’t reply so I left it. I became angry again and upset and its not fair that he gets to have these confrontations and I don’t get to sya my side. So I found him at uni and asked him if this was it now, is it over now? Do I not need to worry about him coming back again? I think I caught him off guard and he was mumbling words. I walked away cos it just wasn’t making sense. He inboxed me that same evening explaining everything saying how hes still not over me but we cant be friends because he doesn’t want to give me false hope. He told me he cant give me the future I want at the moment. I told him its ok I’ll accept it. I thought things were fine I got my closure and I could move on.
    Its been a month 3 weeks now since our last conversation and we said we’d never speak again. my parents have introduced me to this guy who likes me and wants to start a future with me in a year or two but I cant get this uni guy out of my head. I think about him all the time and I honestly didn’t even know I fell this hard. Getting to knw this new guy my parents found for me made me realise how much I actually want to be with the uni guy. Im debating whether to talk to him one last time but I don’t think it would make sense to since he’s told me via facebook inbox that he cant give me what I want and also he’s blocked me now. It feels like he’s moving on and im still stuck in this place. Im so broken up inside, I cant even function at the moment. Its worse than it was before. I dono whether to talk to him or not, he might think im just not moving on but I dno what else to do. He wont talk to me in person though he keeps inboxing instead. I want him to say to my face that he cant give me what I want. Im so broken up please just tell me what to do with this guy?! And what is going through his head?!

  2. @Nad…..We’re really sorry you’re so hurt and confused. But to us, this is very clear. The two of you are not on the same page, and it’s unlikely he’s going to change his mind. It’s his inconsistent communication and mixed-signals that tell us he’s not serious about you. Maybe he was lonely, or wanted sex, or something and that’s why he was contacting you again; but overall, he’s being pretty clear that he can’t give you what you want. So there’s no need to hear it from him face-to-face. However, there’s another issue. Just because this guy isn’t the one, doesn’t mean the guy your parents introduced to you is the one either. We understand that in certain cultures parents are involved in picking a prospective partner, but it’s possible that the reason you’re missing this uni guy so much is the fact that you’re not that into this new guy. What do you think? Any more questions? Ask away. ps. We hope you’ll share our site with all of your friends. Follow us on Twitter; @TGPBuzz. And take a moment to help a fellow reader. Please VOTE on our Ask our Audience page. Thanks!

  3. I posted a question but noticed that you said my question will get answered quicker if I leave it as a comment.
    I’ll try not to go into too much detail but some will be needed to answer my question.
    My husband and I got married in August. We dated for 2 years and I always had problems with his mom. Although she got worse after we got married. Things happened and she got crazier, meaner, and more controlling and basically asked him to choose me or her, he chose her, which absolutely tore me apart.
    We’ve been separated since October and he filed for divorce in November. He has changed his mind several times but now seems to have made a decision considering I haven’t heard from him since Thanksgiving. He seems to be afraid of crossing his mom.
    At one point he blocked me from seeing his facebook which I was okay with and I was ready to move on. Then he unblocks me and I then realize he still has pictures of us and a picture of me saying that I”m his girl up on his facebook and he is still friends with all of my family even though none of them talk to him and some of them are or were mean to him. Some say its a guy thing and most guys don’t consider that and/or he left pictures up because he hasn’t had the chance to take them down but he’s had time to check facebook, block and unblock me, change his relationship status. So why not take down those pictures. I mean why would you want to keep pictures of your ex on facebook for other girls to see.
    Needless to say I’m here hoping that you can shed some light and help me understand why he has unblocked me, kept pictures up of us, and has continued to stay friends with my family. I get we aren’t legally divorced but he has made it loud and clear that he is done with me.
    Please help me. I need some sort of answer.

  4. @Amy…….We’re sorry. This is tough. However, we’re having a strong reaction to your post. We know feelings don’t just disappear overnight, but remember, your husband chose his mom over you? Is he really someone you want back? We hate to say it, but unless he’s using this as a convenient excuse to get divorced—he might be—any guy who chooses their mom over their wife is not mature enough to be in a real relationship. For his own sake, he needs to break away from his mom, gain some independence, mature a bunch, and then he might be ready. But this is unlikely to happen honestly, or if it does, it could take a long, long time. As per your question. We can’t read his mind, but if we were you, we wouldn’t read much into it. ps.Thanks for sharing our site with all of your friends. We appreciate it! Take a moment to help a fellow reader and VOTE on our Ask our Audience page.

  5. I have another question for you guys. When a guy puts on a dating site that they’re looking for friendship or a relationship are they really interested in friendship. Most join dating sites for relationships so if a guy puts friendship on there too is that really what he is looking for.

  6. @Amy…..We can’t imagine that’s what he’s looking for—friendship. It’s probably to make himself seem less threatening, or to let women know he’s not necessarily looking for something serious. Hope that helps.

  7. thanks for the response. i guess you are right and i need to really let go but it hurts so bad. and i just don’t get why he still has to be near me around campus. he’ll choose somewhere near me in the library or in our class that we have together he’ll sit directly opposite me and also he keeps unblocking me and blocking me on facebook. i know i too need to stop stalking and noticing but i can’t help it when all this shows me he still clearly thinks about me. :-\ why can’t we just be together

  8. @nad…..We’re sorry. Hang in there.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*